Dalton Floor Tailor Logo

DIY vs. Professional Installation: Making the Right Flooring Choice

January 16, 2024

Starting a flooring project is an exciting transformation for any space, whether it’s revamping a cozy corner or an entire home. However, one of the crucial decisions that can significantly impact the project’s success and overall satisfaction is choosing between the hands-on approach of DIY installation or the expertise of professional installers.

Each path presents its unique set of advantages and considerations, requiring thoughts on various factors before taking the plunge into flooring renovations. Understanding the complexity of DIY installation and the benefits of hiring seasoned professionals is crucial in navigating this decision-making process.

In this blog, we’ll dive into the significant differences between DIY vs. professional installation, shedding light on the circumstances where each approach shines. By exploring the aspects of cost, skill requirement, time investment, and project scope, we aim to equip you with the knowledge necessary to make an informed decision tailored to your specific flooring aspirations.

Let’s explore DIY endeavors and professional expertise, guiding you toward the most fitting route for your flooring project.

DIY Installation:

Cost-Effectiveness: DIY installation appeals to homeowners seeking to minimize expenses. By taking on the installation themselves, individuals can potentially save on labor costs that would otherwise be included with professional services. This financial advantage is particularly notable in smaller-scale projects where the cost difference between hiring professionals and purchasing materials directly can be significant.

Level of Expertise Required: Certain flooring types work well with the DIY approach, especially for homeowners with moderately useful skills. Click-and-lock systems or peel-and-stick tiles, for instance, are designed to be relatively user-friendly, allowing individuals with basic skills to navigate the installation process. These types of flooring often come with straightforward instructions, making them more manageable for DIY enthusiasts looking to tackle home improvement on their own. Carpet, however, requires specific techniques, particularly when it comes to stretching the carpet properly ahead of time to avoid wrinkles or loose spots. Installing carpet also involves using specialized tools that aren’t typically found in the tool shed.

Time and Effort: Attempting a flooring project in a DIY fashion demands a substantial investment of time and effort. From the initial preparation, which includes acclimating the flooring materials and preparing the subfloor, to the actual installation and potential troubleshooting, each step requires careful attention. Installing your own flooring is not an easy task. It’s crucial to acknowledge that unforeseen challenges or errors during DIY installations might extend the project timeline. Also, individuals should be prepared for the physical demands of the task, ensuring they have the stamina to complete the installation process effectively. 

Materials Needed: The tools needed for a DIY flooring project can vary depending on the type of flooring material you’re installing and which method you choose. Tools can range from inexpensive needs, like chalk lines, measuring tape and mallets to more expensive tools like, saws (jigsaw, circular saw, or miter saw), nail guns, pneumatic staplers, knee kicks, etc. The start-up cost can vary widely based on the tools you already have and the specific flooring material. Generally, expect to spend anywhere from a hundred to several hundred dollars for basic tools if you don’t already own them. Hiring a professional installer might be cheaper in the long run. Also, don’t forget to buy extra flooring materials in case of a mistake. The amount of extra flooring needed varies based on the type of flooring and the complexity of the layout. As a general rule of thumb, it’s recommended to purchase 5-10% more flooring than the square footage of the area you plan to cover. For intricate layouts or unusual room shapes, you might lean toward the higher end of that range to accommodate potential waste.

Resale Value: Homebuyers often have a keen eye for detail, and they might be able to detect a DIY flooring installation based on various factors. The first aspect they will notice is the quality of installation. A professionally installed floor often exhibits a higher level of precision, with seams, transitions, and edges appearing more unified and well-finished compared to a DIY job. Uneven cuts, visible gaps, or improper alignment might signal a DIY installation. Next is consistency. Inconsistent patterns, irregular spacing, or unevenness across the floor can indicate a DIY installation. Professionals typically ensure uniformity throughout the installation process. The third element homebuyers may detect is a visible flaw. DIY installations might have visible flaws, such as adhesive residue, improperly trimmed edges, or mismatched patterns, which can be more noticeable upon closer inspection. The last consideration is the flooring’s longevity and durability. A professionally installed floor tends to have better durability and longevity due to proper techniques and materials used. A floor showing signs of wear or deterioration earlier than expected might suggest a DIY installation with potential flaws, which can turn a homebuyer away.

Professional Installation:

Expertise and Precision: Professional installers bring a large amount of expertise and precision to the table. Their specialized knowledge and experience ensure a meticulous and accurate installation process. They’re experts in handling different flooring materials, understanding subfloor requirements, and applying precise techniques to minimize the potential for errors or imperfections. This expertise ultimately contributes to a superior and long-lasting flooring finish.

Time and Convenience: Hiring professionals offers a level of convenience that goes beyond the actual installation process. Professionals streamline the entire flooring project, from initial assessments to acquiring materials and executing the installation. This approach saves homeowners considerable time and effort. Another advantage is that professionals are equipped to handle unforeseen challenges swiftly, avoiding potential complications that might happen during DIY installations.

Warranty and Guarantees: Professional installations often come bundled with warranties or guarantees (or with the products here at Dalton Floor Tailor!). These guarantees provide homeowners with peace of mind, knowing that their investment is backed by coverage in the event of issues or defects. Warranties typically cover both the materials used and the installation itself, offering a safety net and ensuring that any problems that arise post-installation can be addressed without additional financial burden.

When DIY Works Best

Small-Scale Projects: DIY installations work well for smaller projects or rooms with easy layouts. Spaces that require less intricate cutting or adjustments and have straightforward dimensions are ideal for individuals willing to tackle the installation on their own. This approach allows for manageable tasks and easier troubleshooting.

Basic Flooring Types: Simpler flooring types that don’t involve intricate techniques or specialized tools are good for DIY projects. Materials like laminate flooring or certain types of vinyl that utilize click-and-lock systems or peel-and-stick application methods are more DIY-friendly due to their straightforward installation procedures.

When Professional Installation is Recommended

Complex Flooring Materials: Opting for professional installation is advisable when dealing with complex materials such as hardwood or carpet. These materials often demand specialized techniques, tools, and knowledge for proper installation. Professional installers are equipped to handle the nuances of these materials, ensuring flawless results.

Extensive Areas: For larger areas or projects encompassing multiple rooms, professional installation is recommended for both efficiency and quality. Professional installers have the manpower and expertise to efficiently tackle extensive projects, ensuring consistency and a high standard of workmanship throughout the entire space.


When deciding between DIY installation and hiring professionals for your flooring project, consider crucial factors like your skill level, project complexity, and the type of flooring material. DIY can help you cut back on costs and work well for smaller projects or basic flooring types, but it demands time, effort, and a certain skill level. Professional installation brings expertise, precision, convenience, and peace of mind.

Tailor your decision to your specific circumstances. Reflect on your comfort level with the task and the intricacy of the project. Whether you choose DIY or professional installation, prioritize what aligns best with your needs and abilities for a successful flooring renovation.

The goal is achieving a beautiful, durable, and functional flooring solution for your home without straining yourself. This guide aims to help you make an informed choice, ensuring a satisfying outcome for your unique flooring project.

Share This :